Expensive and softening.

Trading above fair value while the fundamentals weaken — little to like right now.

Price $132.69 taken 2026-11-15 · market cap about $14B
Fair value $64 range $31 to $114 · from the FY26 annual report
Margin of safety −52%, above fair value no margin of safety · the price sits above fair value

The five checks

3 good · 2 warning

  • Warning
    Overvalued
    Fair value ~$64 vs $133 — trading 52% above what the math supports.
  • Good
    Price is in line with its record
    Priced for ~11%/yr, roughly what it has delivered (17.3%/yr).
  • Good
    Revenue still growing
    Up 3.7% last year — demand isn't the problem.
  • Good
    Cash flow compounding
    Free cash flow up ~17.3%/yr — the engine is growing.
  • Warning
    Heavy debt load
    Net debt of $7B — roughly 10× annual free cash flow. This changes the risk picture.

Price against fair value

What today's price assumes

Hold the price fixed and work backwards: how fast would free cash flow have to grow for $133 to make sense?

The price needs ~11% a year
J.M. Smucker has delivered 17.3% a year over the last three years

Price is in line with its record.

Where this number comes from →

How fair value is calculated

No analyst forecasts, no black box, no AI. Six lines from the filing to the answer.

  1. Free cash flow, typical yearThe five-year norm, from the annual reports$0.7B
  2. Ten years of it, growing 5% a year, each counted 9% lessThe same growth and discount for every company$5.9B
  3. Everything after year tenGrowing 2.5% a year, counted the same way+ $7.8B
  4. The business, in today's money$13.7B
  5. Subtract net debtBorrowings and finance leases less cash and securities− $6.9B
  6. Divide by the shares on file÷ 0.1062B

Fair value per share$64

If our assumptions are wrong

Fair value per share under a faster or slower decade, and a gentler or harsher discount. The corners are where the $31 to $114 range comes from.

3% growth5% growth7% growth
8% discount$66$88$114
9% discount$46$64$85
10% discount$31$46$64

The blue cell is the published method. Every cell sits below today’s price.

Free cash flow, ten years

$ billions · Form 10-K

$0.9B FY17 $0.9B FY18 $0.8B FY19 $1.0B FY20 $1.3B FY21 $0.7B FY22 $0.7B FY23 $0.6B FY24 $0.8B FY25 $1.2B FY26
  1. FY26 $1.2B
  2. FY25 $0.8B
  3. FY24 $0.6B
  4. FY23 $0.7B
  5. FY22 $0.7B
  6. FY21 $1.3B
  7. FY20 $1.0B
  8. FY19 $0.8B
  9. FY18 $0.9B
  10. FY17 $0.9B

What the math is really telling you. Watch whether cash flow is compounding — that, more than any single year, is what a value read hangs on.

How this was built. Every figure is computed from The J. M. Smucker Company's SEC filings — no estimates, no AI. Two-stage DCF: 9% discount rate, 5% free-cash-flow growth for 10 years, 2.5% terminal. Free cash flow is operating cash flow less capital spending. Fair value is based on typical free cash flow over the last five years ($0.7B), not the latest year ($1.2B), which sat 61% above the company's own norm. Net cash is cash and marketable securities less borrowings, commercial paper and finance leases; operating leases are disclosed but never counted as debt. We subtract net debt from the value of the business — for J.M. Smucker that is about $7B, or $65 per share. Fundamentals are from the FY26 annual report and change only when a new one is filed. Price of $132.69 taken 2026-11-15 (Google Finance, manual entry, 2026-11-13) — it is not live and does not move during the day.

Read J.M. Smucker another way

TickerMath is an educational tool, not investment advice — it computes one model from SEC filings and can be wrong. How we compute this →