Want to find your lens? Five questions, no jargon — they tell you which of four reads fits how you already think.
Expensive and softening.
Trading above fair value while the fundamentals weaken — little to like right now.
The five checks
3 good · 2 warning
- WarningOvervaluedFair value ~$64 vs $133 — trading 52% above what the math supports.
- GoodPrice is in line with its recordPriced for ~11%/yr, roughly what it has delivered (17.3%/yr).
- GoodRevenue still growingUp 3.7% last year — demand isn't the problem.
- GoodCash flow compoundingFree cash flow up ~17.3%/yr — the engine is growing.
- WarningHeavy debt loadNet debt of $7B — roughly 10× annual free cash flow. This changes the risk picture.
Price against fair value
What today's price assumes
Hold the price fixed and work backwards: how fast would free cash flow have to grow for $133 to make sense?
Price is in line with its record.
How fair value is calculated
No analyst forecasts, no black box, no AI. Six lines from the filing to the answer.
- Free cash flow, typical yearThe five-year norm, from the annual reports$0.7B
- Ten years of it, growing 5% a year, each counted 9% lessThe same growth and discount for every company$5.9B
- Everything after year tenGrowing 2.5% a year, counted the same way+ $7.8B
- The business, in today's money$13.7B
- Subtract net debtBorrowings and finance leases less cash and securities− $6.9B
- Divide by the shares on file÷ 0.1062B
Fair value per share$64
If our assumptions are wrong
Fair value per share under a faster or slower decade, and a gentler or harsher discount. The corners are where the $31 to $114 range comes from.
| 3% growth | 5% growth | 7% growth | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8% discount | $66 | $88 | $114 |
| 9% discount | $46 | $64 | $85 |
| 10% discount | $31 | $46 | $64 |
The blue cell is the published method. Every cell sits below today’s price.
Free cash flow, ten years
$ billions · Form 10-K
What the math is really telling you. Watch whether cash flow is compounding — that, more than any single year, is what a value read hangs on.
How this was built. Every figure is computed from The J. M. Smucker Company's SEC filings — no estimates, no AI. Two-stage DCF: 9% discount rate, 5% free-cash-flow growth for 10 years, 2.5% terminal. Free cash flow is operating cash flow less capital spending. Fair value is based on typical free cash flow over the last five years ($0.7B), not the latest year ($1.2B), which sat 61% above the company's own norm. Net cash is cash and marketable securities less borrowings, commercial paper and finance leases; operating leases are disclosed but never counted as debt. We subtract net debt from the value of the business — for J.M. Smucker that is about $7B, or $65 per share. Fundamentals are from the FY26 annual report and change only when a new one is filed. Price of $132.69 taken 2026-11-15 (Google Finance, manual entry, 2026-11-13) — it is not live and does not move during the day.
Read J.M. Smucker another way
TickerMath is an educational tool, not investment advice — it computes one model from SEC filings and can be wrong. How we compute this →